Trucking Advocates Push FMCSA for Hair Testing Decisions as Health Ruling Awaits

Hair Samples for Drug Testing: A Proposal Sparks Mixed Reactions

A recent proposal to include hair samples in drug testing for a federal database has elicited diverse opinions from both executives and drivers.

Public Commentary Invited by FMCSA

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) sought public feedback in August on whether hair test results should be added to the agency’s Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse and shared with other organizations. Currently, hair testing is not approved in federal programs, and the health department is still evaluating a proposal submitted in September 2020, as noted by FMCSA and health officials.

Support for Hair Testing

Carriers have been permitted to utilize hair samples for drug screening in potential hires. Proponents argue that hair tests contribute to road safety because they detect drugs more effectively than urine tests do.

Opposition and Concerns

However, opponents have voiced numerous concerns. They point out the additional financial burden that hair testing may impose on smaller carriers, alongside research indicating that various physical factors can lead to differing drug test results, potentially resulting in discrimination.

HHS Determination Required

The FMCSA has asserted that the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) must first determine whether federal programs can incorporate hair samples in drug testing. This prerequisite emphasizes the need for a thorough examination of the implications involved.

Showcasing Stakeholder Perspectives

To underscore the differing viewpoints on this matter, Transport Dive compiled recent comments to illustrate the positions held by various stakeholders.